Sunday, 19 November 2023

Morality and The Market for Nyege Nyege

Even if you don’t like a market, those markets exist in practice. The question is not whether they should exist or not but how to regulate them.

Jean Tirole, Morality and the Markets, 2018 Keynes Lecture

Greetings. Jinja has been a hive of activity during the month of November. From the eighth edition of Nyege Nyege to the Royal wedding of His Highness William Nadiope Gabula, the fifth Kyabazinga of Busoga. Both events have attracted tourists to the newly minted city. However, it is the festivities of the former that I would wish to focus my attention.

A year ago, the first Nyege Nyege edition to be held since the advent of Covid was met with collective disdain from leaders across the political, cultural and religious circles. The festival is a leading essential music and arts celebration held over the course of four days. Noted for its “wanton and hedonism”, it attracts visitors from the world over. Nevertheless, its detractors chose to focus on the pleasure-seeking aspects, calling for outlawing the festival.



The matter went as far as the Uganda legislature. One Member of Parliament from Busoga spurn a conspiracy theory of Busoga being chosen to host the “immoral festival” to the ruin of its youth, whilst the other regions were left to maintain their moral values and subsequently prosper. The Members of Parliament voted to have the festival banned on Tuesday 06th September but two days later, the Prime Minister had the ban overturned. Up to that point, that was the highest-ranking government official to back the festival. Ms. Robinah Nabanja’s reasons; 

“… cancellation would be challenging. We also have to think about the economy.”

It is the economy, stupid!

The 2023 edition on the other hand has not been met with any opposition. If anything, it has the backing of previous moralists. The Busoga Kingdom Minister for Tourism spoke at the Press launch encouraging people to attend.

What happened between the 2022 and 2023 to make Nyege Nyege more palatable, could be explained by the nexus between morality and the markets. To the economist, morality can be simplified to the basic tenet of “do no harm”; ensuring our actions don’t have negative externalities. As defined by Tirole, an externality occurs when a non-consenting sub-party who might be affected by a transaction between two parties. For the case of Nyege Nyege, the neighbours of the venue who are affected by the noise pollution from the festival serves as an example of a negative externality.

For a case when the positive externalities outweigh the negative externalities, we are likely to have a net positive social benefit, and there are numerous positive externalities from the festival. The transaction between the revelers and the hosts has a trickle-down effect to the hotels in Jinja, restaurant owners, artisans, transporters and tour companies; these services account for 68.8% of tourism spend in the country.

In 2022, over 8,000 foreign visitors were reported to have bought tickets to the festival, for a country that registered a 2022 average of 2,230 daily foreign visitors to the country, that's a telling stat about the four-day event's impact on tourism. Little wonder the recent tourism report has the Eastern region second to Kampala in occupancy rate. Furthermore, these are 2,000 new people to be introduced to the rolex (not the watch) everyday!

With the extent of the positive externalities, one can discern why Ms. Nabbanja pushed for the festival to be reinstated and the subsequent acceptance it has received.

To cap off, borrowing from the opening quote, it seems we have come to terms with the fact that the market for Nyege Nyege exists and how we regulate it matters. "It should not be a moral posture, but a more practical thing," surmised Tirole. 

Ceteris. Paribus.


References

Ministry of Tourism. (2023). Annual Tourism Development Performance Review Report 2022/2023. Ministry of Tourism. https://www.tourism.go.ug/single-post/annual-tourism-development-performance-review-report-2022-2023-launched

Nafula, J., Kamurungi, E., & Maloba, P. (2022, September 08). Nyege Nyege: Nabbanja, Among reading from different scripts. The Daily Monitor. https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/nyege-nyege-nabbanja-among-read-from-different-scripts-3941010  

Ndagire, B. (2023, September 27).76% of Uganda's tourists come from East Africa. The Daily Monitor. https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/business/markets/76-of-uganda-s-tourists-come-from-east-africa--4381708#:~:text=The%20Tourism%20Development%20Programme%20Annual,arrivals%20registered%20in%20the%20period

Onyango-Obbo, C. (2022, September 14). Nyege Nyege and ghosts of Uganda’s north-south divide. The Daily Monitor. https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/oped/columnists/charles-onyango-obbo/nyege-nyege-and-ghosts-of-uganda-s-north-south-divide-3947740

Parliament Uganda. (2022, September 06). Parliament perturbed over Nyege Nyege festival. Parliament Uganda. https://www.parliament.go.ug/news/6174/parliament-perturbed-over-nyege-nyege-festival

Tirole, J. (2018, March 01). Morality and the Market. The 2017-2018 Keynes Lecture, Cambridge University. https://www.keynesfund.econ.cam.ac.uk/keynes-lecture-1718-videos


Friday, 11 August 2023

Father Unto Many ...

[LONG READ ALERT] 

Why, ’tis a happy thing / To be the father unto many ...

— HENRY VI PART 3, ACT III SCENE 2 


Greetings. Last Saturday (05th August) my family was treated to a commemoration event, honouring the work and legacy of our father, John Richard Isabirye. Both my parents are teachers and have spent their careers in service as teachers and administrators both in the public and private spheres. Having skipped Fathers' Day (and Mothers' Day) articles this year, this is a late contribution to those days.

We have been fortunate to have had both our parents under the same roof during our entire lives and the memories are quite many to dig from. I am the eighth of nine children, and as such I always assumed everything I went through or experienced they had seen plenty of times before. One time I was sent home from school (during Mr. Barnabas Langoya's tenure as Deputy HM at Namilyango, he was always reluctant to issue suspensions; he just sent home students who were unfortunate enough to be up to no good as the visitation day approached, and they were to report on the appointed day with their parents for a one-on-one meeting with him. Nothing went on your disciplinary record after the session.) Back to the pseudo-suspension; yes, I realised it was easier to notify my father than my mother - the nurturing instinct would prompt her to pick me from school whereas my father would just wait for me to travel to Jinja.


During my 5-day stay at home, we discussed my experiences preparing for the A'Level exams. There was neither scolding nor punishment. My elder siblings in similar positions had different experiences (one was denied a lift during his suspension, yet both he and our father were headed in the same direction; for most of them it was long lectures or extra chores, as the rod was heavily spared by him in the household). Perhaps he had grown old. But I would like to think, it was his parenting muscle in the long run. For parents who've been teachers as well, they have probably experienced all sorts of misdemenaour from children that nothing surprises them anymore. But in our session with Mr. Langoya, his message stood out. It doesn't matter how bright you are; but without character, you might not be able to achieve your goals. That message stuck. And as the celebrations on Saturday carried on, majority of his former students and colleagues echoed this message in varying ways. 

Origins of the Isabirye Character

As with most Africans, the family name is a concept we adopted in the 20th century. The clan was the core. We belong to the Makiika clan in Busoga, whose totem is the Buffalo. Our words are Mpa ateghola, n'omugaiga y'eghola, translated as we all borrow including the rich, but laced with a deeper meaning of "collective action yielding progress". The clan name arises from the founder, named Makiika, and along with Namakiika are probably the most important names a clan member can be given. Other names include Kigenyi, Wakabi, Dhamusanga, Kafuko, Kamanyiro for boys; and Nakaziba, Namuwooya, Nakizibu for girls.

Our grandfather, Akisoferi Kafuko, was a man with ambitions beyond his means. He was educated up to Primary Six and then sought to join Uganda Police training school. While at police training one of his fellow cadets was visited by his brother who was smartly dressed in a sweater (might have been a shirt) with a red lion emblazoned on it. On inquiring, he was told that was the school uniform of then King's School Budo (prior to being renamed King's College). He so admired it and the way the fellow in the uniform carried himself. The brother to Kafuko's fellow cadet happened to be Godfrey Binaisa, future President of Uganda. His admiration for education stems from the character embodied by that gentleman that day. Dhadha Kafuko went on to serve in the Uganda Police and in the Busoga Civil Service as a Gombolola chief. He was proud of his career, but he believed he could have done better had he been educated. Given his police background, he always believed in order, discipline and a smartly dressed appearance. He ensured to take all his eleven children through school, and pressed them to have ambitions beyond his own.

 

John Richard Isabirye, named Isabirye after Kafuko's own grandfather, is the second of our grandfather's children. He mentions he didn't have a name for the first few days of his existence, as Dhadha Kafuko was stationed in Masaka at the time. His childhood was spent in Iganga and Mukono, with his parents and his maternal grandmother. After Primary and Junior Secondary School, he was admitted to Kiira College Butiki in 1963. The school was just 4 years old, and his was the fourth Senior One intake. Butiki had been set up to cater for the rising demand of education in Busoga, and at the time Busoga College Mwiri was a national school taking in students from all corners of the country. As a new school, it had a smaller population and as such you could get to know everyone in your class and probably the school. There was even more contact time with teachers. The Headmaster, Mr. Robert H. Freak, used to host weekly dinners with students, to get to know them and their aspirations better. Our father carried a similar concept in his house; at the dinner table during holidays each one of us would be assessed, get to explain his follies and successes of the year, what they are grateful for. The Harkness table is not only in the classroom but can be enforced in the dining as well.

He wanted to go beyond where his father had stopped, and after his Diploma in Education from the Institute of Teacher Education, Kyambogo, he won a Commonwealth Scholarship to the University of Calgary, in Alberta, Canada.  He obtained a Bachelor of Arts in Education, and he mentioned trying out for the akapiira k'abazungu (Canadian Football or Rugby Football, both games were available at Calgary). In 1995, he would obtain a Master of Arts in Education Administration and Planning, from Makerere University.

Education Career

He returned to Uganda and took up a teaching position at his former school, Butiki. His subjects were geography, biology and physical education. By this time, Butiki had a bigger roll compared to his schooling days. Still, he believed the teacher must know all his students by name, where they come from and what their parents do.

There has never been an era in this country where teachers have had a fair share. The teachers' salaries have been underwhelming throughout the history of education in this country. Part of this can be attributed to the fact that the first teachers were missionaries; men and women who had sworn vows of poverty were happy to take home close to nothing in the 1920s and 1930s. The teachers who took up the positions after were lay people who had children to look after, and the African native teachers also owed a "black tax" to their families and communities. The economic slow down of the 1970s didn't help; there was rationing and people had to queue for basic necessities. Our father told a story of how people would walk for hours just to line up. Jinja College was closer to town than Butiki (3km vs 9km), and as such the Butiki teachers had to wake up earlier to beat their JiCo counterparts to the queue. At 14km, the Mwiri people were best served harvesting the sugarcanes in Kakira than trekking to town for sugar rations! But those times are behind us now.

Our father sought opportunities in Kenya; he interviewed and was offered a job. However, his father appealed to him to stay. He never reveals what was discussed at length, but as one of the elders, his siblings needed someone to look up to; an example close to home than one far away. I have observed our father appeal to my elder brother in the same manner; you have to buy a car/own a house, so that your younger brothers have someone to look up to. Delegation of responsibility through your elder children is also an important ethos that my grandfather and father have passed on to us.

His stay was richly rewarded. He became a Deputy Headmaster at Butiki, and in 1981 was named acting Head master. As the students returned for his first term as Headmaster, one individual pointed out "Isabirye is the Headmaster! Nga tulabye; the man knows every student by name!" Perhaps that was code for "we can't hide our impish behaviour from this one!" But it served him well; whatever the teachers reported to him in the weekly staff meetings, he already had a clue about. 

Steward of Others

A parent, after all, is the steward of another creature's life

— Steven Levitt & Stephen Dubner, Freakonomics, Chapter 5: What Makes a Perfect parent

Our grandfather believed responsibility is best handled by married people (those were the days before Bukedde TV came to life and changed that perception). He urged our father to get married. A year after his appointment, he got married to Phida Naigaga. I have no regrets having two teachers for parents; we were on school holiday at the same time of the year and to me the normal has always been having both parents present. 

Both our parents believed in delegation, and the role teachers can play in the development of their children. None of us was educated in Butiki for reasons of objectivity. Teachers are parents with hyper objectivity. He believed if one of his sons was schooling in Butiki and he misbehaved, a teacher would be faced with a dilemma. Discipline the HM's child which is the right thing to do and you don't know how your boss will react to this. Let the child continue down that path unchecked, in order not to antagonise your boss and the child loses out, and the teacher as well, because there is utility derived from shaping an upright child. To avoid these situations, my parents chose to send their children to schools where they would get objective treatment; perhaps had I been in Butiki I would have a clean record with no suspension from Mr. Langoya! After my father left Butiki, the old stock of teachers were keen on names like Isabirye, Kafuko and they wondered whether they were related to him.

On the Education of Girls

At the age of 50, our father had been HM at Butiki for 15 years, and he had 5 years until the mandatory age of retirement. There was an attempt to transfer him to Mwiri, which was blocked by a coalition of parents, teachers and students. This incident set a precedent, that has been repeated years later where the Butiki faithful can have a say in who gets to run the school. The incident was an eye-opener for one, he was a public servant whose mandate could be allocated to any place without being consulted. And as retirement was approaching, he needed to keep busy. Education is all my parents knew, and so they decided to set up a school that would occupy their time during retirement.

He had purchased a house in 1993 at Old Kakira Road, Wanyange village. About 3km from the house, on a hill, he acquired another piece of land to set up the school. The proximity would make it easier to supervise. What type of school to set up was determined by three factors. The school had to be set up before he left his position at Butiki. This would thrust him into potential conflict of interest. As Butiki was a boys-only school, he chose to set-up a girls only school; thinking of them as different education market segments. Therefore the professional ethos of avoiding a conflict of interest mattered to him. The second factor was that in retirement he was to perform a limited role, and our mother was to play a considerable role. The development of girls was something she would know more about than him. A third factor, surrounds income disparities in Uganda, and particularly Busoga region. In poor households, there is not enough income to send all children to school, and as a result parents have to choose which children to focus on. In most cases, the boys are favoured more than the girls. He believed at this stage of his career, he could use his platform to demonstrate to people the benefits of educating women and girls.

The school was setup in 1998, originally in the Old Kakira road home before it was transferred to its current site on the hill. This first crop of students proudly refer to themselves as pioneers, and have been a guiding example for cohorts that have followed in their footsteps.

By the time of his retirement in 2001, Nakanyonyi Girls' School was five years old and had presented one candidate class for the UCE exams. For Kiira College Butiki, he was leaving it having been part of it for 34 years of its then 46-year existence. He was rewarded handsomely by the Old Boys, with a vehicle. 

Education is an important tool, irrespective of your background, this was echoed by Hon. Manjeri Kyabakutika (Jinja Woman MP and former student of Nakanyonyi). Our father chose to maintain many students in school even without them paying their school dues because of this belief. There are studies that show that students from poor backgrounds tend to lag behind in academic achievement compared to their more affluent peers. As an example, if a student is sent home until the parents have enough money to repay the fees, he is bound to miss out on the classes attained by his/her peers who paid school fees. The student therefore has to work over time to catch up. He sought to rectify this by offering students scholarships. It's a game of numbers; 99 paying students can condense the costs of 1 extra non-paying student. And if the non-paying student performs well in the national exams, it can thrust the school in the national spotlight making the school more attractive to both academically bright students and students whose income backgrounds mean they can afford to pay the school dues. By this principle, countless students managed to receive an education by our parents' generosity.

Conclusion 

It is often said teachers never age, but I think rightly they never retire. They are always guiding be it in their homes or in the community. Same with parents; they never retire. Once you become a parent, you've committed for life to nurture and put other people's interests before your own. I have always known that as part of their background as teachers, our parents are responsible for a myriad of people way beyond their children. It was a pleasant sight to see that their efforts all those years produced upstanding individuals who have contributed to society. We appreciate the gestures by the Old Boys of Butiki, the Old Girls of Nakanyonyi, the former teachers of both schools, and the parents. 

Before I left Jinja, I told our father that he put us in a difficult position. He "refused to fail while he's alive"; and as such we, the children, cannot afford failure or we will be judged harshly. Dhadha Kafuko had the vision, Isabirye built the character and ethos. It is our duty to uphold their legacy.

Ceteris. Paribus.


PS: Given that this is the first post in close to six months, I feel I owe the readers an explanation for my long absence. Having completed the rigours of graduate study, I believed I had earned some off time from cerebral pursuits for a while. I know it's an absurdly long explanation for writer's block but I shall be back on track, and hopefully with more constructive material.








Sunday, 12 February 2023

The White Man Giveth And The White Man Taketh

Greetings. The 2023 General Synod of the Church of England passed major resolutions for the global Anglican Church. The General Synod, which serves as the legislative assembly for the global Anglican Communion, voted for clergy to confer blessings on same-sex unions, as well as revisiting the wording of the Lord’s Prayer to acknowledge a gender-neutral god. Leaders of the Anglican church in other countries have expressed their disdain towards the proposed policies. The Archbishop of the Church of Uganda issued a statement denouncing the mother church and proposing to initiate the process of splitting from the Church of England. Irrespective of which side one falls in the ideological divide on same-sex relations, this case was the latest reminder on the folly of Africans designing their anti-homosexuality arguments based on western religious thought.

The White Man Giveth And The White Man Taketh

The Church of England has its origins in the sixteenth century English reformation, and the English monarchy Henry VIII’s desire to annul his marriage yet Pope Clement VII kept thwarting his requests. However, on a much grander scale, Henry VIII was seeking to have greater autonomy in his domain. Henry therefore proceeded to have Parliament declare him Head of the Church in England. To bring the clergy on board, the king “bullied, bribed, or blackmailed” most of them. The Church was born out of one man’s political and personal machinations, and the opportunity presented to him by the reformation.



During the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century, religion was used as a political and socio-cultural tool by the colonialists. Firstly, in a race to have the most converts, the European missionaries sowed deep divisions amongst the Africans. Kinsmen were at cross purposes for as long as each belonged to a different branch of Christianity. In the career advancement of native Africans, religion played a major role and those who found themselves sticking to the faith of their forefathers were greatly disenfranchised.

Secondly, Africans were made to feel inferior about their culture. This inferiority complex has pushed Africans away from appreciating and utilising the tenets of this culture to tell their stories and defend their points of view. Therefore, their arguments have been fostered in foreign languages with foreign ideas. As Ngugi wa Thiong'o once wrote, African thinkers have come to be defined and to define themselves "in terms of the languages of Imperialist imposition". In this way, majority of arguments against homosexuality have been crafted around the Bible. Like most of the western-borrowed institutions utilised by Africans today, Christianity’s rules are dictated miles away on European soil. It was only a matter of time that the Church would okay same-sex unions and possibly rewrite the Bible and vanquish the very arguments that have been used by Africans for decades.

Anyone with a familiar grasp of church history would know that almost every single pillar of Christianity has been debated. The very divinity of Jesus was debated at the first Council of Nicaea in 325 A.D. (God the Son was adopted, so to speak). The modern concept of an academic dissertation defence has its origins in Church proceedings of the canonisation of saints; priests debate on the merits of a candidate for sainthood, and there’s an assigned “Devil’s advocate” to find faults that would deter the candidate’s ascension to sainthood! Therefore the church – whether Anglican, Catholic or Orthodox – has always had a tradition of discussing propositions to adapt the religion to the changing times.

The Christian basis for African arguments against homosexuality have had their day. As with most Euroscentric institutions, the rules change and we just have to adapt them. If only we knew what Wanga, Mukasa and Unkulunkulu thought about this issue. Sadly, we will never know.

Ceteris. Paribus.


References

Editor, (February 2023). Church of England split over gay vote ‘obvious’. The Daily Monitor, retrieved 12th February 2023.

Shagan, E. H. (2019). The Emergence of the Church of England, c.1520-1553. The Oxford history of Anglicanism; Volume 1: Reformation and identity, c.1520-1662, 28-44.

Sherwood, H., (09th February 2023). Church of England votes in favour of blessings for same-sex unions. The Guardian, retrieved 12th February 2023.

Wa Thiong'o, N. (1998). Decolonising the mind. Diogenes, 46(184), 101-104.

Saturday, 31 December 2022

When The Race To Become G.O.A.T Was A Black Duopoly

Ashton Kutcher: What do you call 1 black man being chased by 300 white men?

Kellee Stewart: What?

Ashton Kutcher: The P.G.A Tour

Guess Who (2005) 


Greetings. Legendary footballer Edson Arantes do Nascimento, nicknamed Pelé, passed on recently. Considered one of the greatest footballers of all time, tributes and obituaries are pouring in from around the world. People of my father's generation (hit their 20s in the late 60s) are staunch supporters of Brazil owing to the legacy of Pele. He dominated the sport, turning Santos football club from a little known regional club to a global powerhouse. He won three World Cup medals with Brazil, the only man to achieve that feat. The German legend Franz Backenbauer, himself a double World Cup winner, referred to him as the greatest footballer of all time. Given that Pele played during a time when media was not as big as it is today and most people living today never watched him play, his achievements are not fully appreciated today. Furthermore, as a black man, he rose to prominence during a when racism was an established policy in some countries. His death comes right after the conclusion of the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Qatar,  where Argentina secured a third World Cup crown and finally settled the debate over the Lionel Messi-Cristiano Ronaldo debate. In light of that debate, I examine the G.O.A.T debate from the 1960s, which involved two black players

The First Black Footballer

Andrew Watson is on record as the first black football player. The son of a Scottish sugar plantation owner and a Caribbean native woman, Watson first featured for Glasgow side Maxwell FC in 1876, before having stints at Park Grove, Queens Park (where he won 3 Scottish Cups), Swifts (where he was the first black player to play in the FA Cup) and Corinthians. In 1887, he signed for Bootle FC in England, becoming the first black professional football player.

O Rei: Pele vs Eusebio

By the 1960s, football had spread across the globe with many countries conducting both a national league and a national knockout tournament (cup), and continental club competitions were taking shape in Europe, South America, Africa and Asia. The number of black footballers was significantly larger than it had been 80 years before. The two main draws of the time were the black footballers Eusebio da Silva of Portugal and Pelé, whose dates of birth were separated by 13 months. Pelé had announced himself to the World at the 1958 World Cup, becoming the first black player to score in a World Cup final. The Mozambique-born Eusebio would go on to become the first non-white European player to win the Ballon d'Or in 1965. Both played for Portuguese-speaking nations and were nicknamed O Rei (The King).

Pelé (left) and Eusebio (right), 1966 World Cup


The football world of 1960s is far removed from that of today. The fixture list was certainly less congested than it is today. The European Champion Clubs Cup (European Cup), precursor to the Champions League, was played on a knock-out basis with only one slot per nation (the League winners). Pre-season matches did not involve travelling to Asia or North America for friendly games. Therefore, European opposition and South American opposition only met during the World Cup, the few international friendlies, or at club level in the Intercontinental Cup – which was contested between the winners of the European Cup and South America's Copa Libertadores. Therefore, in their prime, Pele and Eusebio played each other on 3 occasions.

Over the course of 2 games of the Intercontinental Cup in 1962, Pelé scored 5 goals to his rival's solitary contribution, as Santos edged Benfica 8-4 on aggregate. Their only meeting in national team colours saw Eusebio master 2 goals as Portugal eliminated Brazil from the 1966 World Cup. The stats in those 3 games were; goals 5-3 in favour of Pele, hattricks 1-0 in favour of Pele, and wins 2-1 in favour of Pele.

In the 1970s, both players moved to the nascent North American League, Pelé featuring for the New York Cosmos as Eusebio featured for the Boston Minutemen and later Toronto. In their first meeting Eusebio opened the scoring for Boston, while Pelé's equaliser was ruled out. The game ended 2-1 in Boston's favour. Each secured the league title, Eusebio with Toronto in 1976 and Pele bested him the following year. 

PELE

 

EUSEBIO

17

LEAGUE

12

4

CUPS

14

2

CONTINENTAL CUPS

1

2

INTERCONTINENTAL CUP

0

766

CLUB GAMES

575

709

CLUB GOALS

580

3

WORLD CUPS

0

0

COPA AMERICA/EURO

0

0

WORLD CUP GOLDEN BOOT

1 (1966)

0

BALLON D'OR

1 (1965)

92

NATIONAL TEAM GAMES

64

77

NATIONAL TEAM GOALS

41

 

Pelé enjoyed more success compared to his Mozambique-born rival. With regards to individual awards, Pelé was named the 1973 South American footballer of the year. Having played outside Europe, he was ineligible for the Ballon d'Or. However, France Football retrospectively named him Ballon d'Or winner for 1958-61, 1963-64, and 1970. 

Key

 

PELE

EUSEBIO

MARADONA

ZIDANE

CRISTIANO

MESSI

NATION

BRAZIL

PORTUGAL

ARGENTINA

FRANCE

PORTUGAL

ARGENTINA

D.O.B

23/10/40

25/01/42

30/10/60

23/06/72

05/02/85

24/06/87

LEAGUE

17

12

3

3

7

11

CUP

4

14

3

0

6

7

EC/CL

2

1

0

1

5

4

IC/FCWC

2

0

0

2

4

3

CA

766

575

589

695

951

831

CG

709

580

311

125

701

695

FWC

3

0

1

1

0

1

EUR/CA

0

0

0

1

1

1

FCC

0

0

0

0

0

0

OL

0

0

0

0

0

1

NA

92

64

91

108

196

172

NG

77

61

34

31

118

98

FIFA BEST

0

0

0

3

3

2

Bd'OR

0

1

0

1

5

7

KEY:

  • LEAGUE – National Leagues (and for the case of Brazil, State Leagues)
  • CUP – National Cups (both national cups and national league cups)
  • EC/CL – club continental tournament, i.e., European Cup (Champions League) and Copa Libertadores
  • IC/FCWC – Intercontinental Cup or FIFA Club World Cup
  • CA – Club appearances
  • CG – Club goals scored
  • FWC – FIFA World Cup
  • EUR/CA – European Championship (Euro)/ Copa America
  • FCCC – FIFA Confederations Cup
  • OL – Olympic Games
  • NA – National team appearances
  • NG – National team goals scored
  • FIFA BEST – FIFA Player of the Year Award
  • Bd'OR – Ballon d'Or

 

From the above comparison, in different parameters each individual fares differently. Pele has the highest number of League titles and World Cups. However, it is important to consider that in the Brazilian football system, clubs play in the regional league and then proceed to the national league, granting a player two shorts at a league title in one year. Messi and Cristiano have more individual awards compared to Pelé, Eusebio and Maradona owing to the fact that the FIFA Best Player Award was launched in 1991 and the Ballon d'Or is only eligible for European based players, of which Pelé never played for a European Club.

For one who is considered the greatest, Diego Maradona and Zinedine Zidane scored an alarmingly fewer number of goals compared to their rivals. However, Zidane ticks more trophy boxes than Maradona. An individual player features for both a football club and a national team. At club level, the chances of silverware are the league, the cup (league cups are rarer across the globe, mainly being played in UK), and the continental tournament (Champions League, Copa Libertadores, CAF Confederations Cup, etc). For the national team, the player has the continental tournament (Euros, Copa America, AFCON, Asian Cup, etc) and the World Cup. I already showed that the black G.O.A.T debate was settled by Pelé ticking more boxes than Eusebio at club and national team level. The only box Pelé never ticked was Copa America, finishing runner-up in 1959 at a tournament where he collected the golden boot with 8 goals and best player of the tournament. Eusebio never played in any final for his country.

Maradona ticked less boxes at club level compared to his rivals. If the status was attained through trophy haul and less media frenzy, the two black superstars of the 1960s would be held in higher regard than him.

The Once And Future G.O.A.T

Despite coming up second in the 2022 World Cup final, France fired a warning short to the rest of the World. Seven of their starting XI were under 30, with the entire substitution bench made up of players born after 1995. Their talisman Kylian Mbappe, whose parents are Cameroonian and Algerian respectively, netted 3 goals to keep Les Blues in the game until the penalty shootout. Still under 25, Mbappe has already scored more national team goals (36) than Maradona and Zidane. He has played at two World Cups, and on each occasion has played in the final, and has netted more goals (4) in the final than Maradona (0! Come on Maradona, even Marco Materazzi scored a goal in the 2006 final!), Messi (2), Zidane (3) and Pelé (3). After 52 years, a black man has again put his hand up for the G.O.A.T debate. 

In line with Kutcher's quote from the 2005 movie Guess Who, Mbappe is on the brink of replicating Tiger Wood's pre-eminence of the white-dominated golf, just as Pelé did for football in 1960s.

Ceteris. Paribus.

References

Falk, G., (8th March 2021). Andrew Watson: Scotland Remembers First Black Footballer 100 Years On From His Death. The Scotsman. Retrieved on 29th December 2022.

McParlan, P., (21st August 2018). Remembering Three Rare But Momentous Occasions When Pelé and Eusebio Squared Off. These Football Times. Retrieved 30th December 2022

Introducing Isa Metrics

Greetings. I welcome you all to the New Year. I begin 2024 with good news, particularly for me, but hopefully with time, for my readers as w...